Dork Radio
Now playing:
In the mag...
Featuring Foals, King Nun, Pumarosa, Feet and loads more.
Order a copy
November 2019
Review

Protomartyr - Relatives in Descent

The relentless, shapeless gloom can get a bit much.
Protomartyr - Relatives in Descent
Published: 9:51 am, September 27, 2017
The relentless, shapeless gloom can get a bit much.

Label: Domino
Released: 29th September 2017
Rating: ★★

In these troubled times, ‘In these troubled times…’ has become a reviewing crutch almost as wearying as the act of switching the news on - or swiping down to refresh - itself: what fresh hell awaits? Music is expected to be a comforting balm, a joyous distraction, or to confront the encroaching horrors with righteous vitriol, often all at the same time.

Now Detroit’s Protomartyr wade in, following 2015’s well-received ‘The Agent Intellect’ with a fourth LP, tackling the fake news age and universal skepticism. “There’s no shared reality,” ponders singer Joe Casey. “Maybe there never was.” But rather than hitting it head-on, ‘Relatives In Descent’ prefers poetry to punches, abstracts to anger; a postpunk fog to passion and fury.

This works well in places - the stumbling, stuttering discord of the opening ‘A Private Understanding’, steadily building to a thundering chorus; ‘My Children’’s bruising melody; or ‘Here Is The Thing’ - like The Fall meets, well, The Fall, down to Casey’s occasional Mark E. Smith-ian -ahs at the ends of lines - but the relentless, shapeless gloom can get a bit much.

‘The Chuckler’ seems to recognise this, sarcastically suggesting “I guess I’ll keep on chuckling/till there’s no more breath in my lungs”, but there’s little to recommend the dreary likes of ‘Windsor Hum’ or ‘Up The Tower’, where a nicely gathering tension leads to an exercise in making nothing out of something.

Only ‘Male Plague’ and ‘Night Blooming Cereus’ buck the trends, the first reading like a fairly direct swipe at toxic masculinity, and the second - “Only in darkness does the flower take hold/It blooms at night” - finding occasional patches of colour, and hope, amid darkness. We could do with a few more - both here, and in these troubled times. Rob Mesure

Give all this a try

Check out Beabadoobee's brand new 'Space Cadet' EP
Listen

Check out Beabadoobee's brand new 'Space Cadet' EP

It's here in full, streaming early!
Cast your vote in the Dork Reader's Poll 2019!
HRRRNK!

Cast your vote in the Dork Reader's Poll 2019!

It's that time again! Tell us what you've been into this year.
Jack Peñate has announced plans for his third album, 'After You'
Incoming!

Jack Peñate has announced plans for his third album, 'After You'

Check out another new track from the long-awaited record, 'Murder'.
The Murder Capital have a brand new tour for 2020
On tour

The Murder Capital have a brand new tour for 2020

They've also dropped a new video for 'More Is Less'.
Like this? Subscribe to Dork and get every issue delivered direct to your door anywhere on the planet.
CONTACT PRIVACY ADVERTISE

© 2018 The Bunker Publishing